Friday, October 21, 2011

ROAD TEST

Volvo S60: Road Test

by Sopan Sharma Photography: Kunal Khadse Posted on 02 May 2011152850 Views7 Comments
One second it's a plush, safe family sedan; the other it's a roaring tarmac scorcher throwing you back in the seat. The Volvo S60 is the sort of a car that can be what you want it to be, all delivered in a sweet and sexy package. We return stumped



Get alerts on new cars reviewed by ZigWheels

As the new car rolls into the ZigWheels garage, its pretty, shiny orange paintjob complimenting the lithe, muscular and likeable lines of a sedan, one cannot help but letch. ‘Naughty but Nice’ is what Volvo has been aiming for with its new range of cars, attempting to ditch its serious, safe but somewhat staid image by adding a liberal sprinkling of style all-round, and the XC60 SUV managed to do hit the target, even if it still had a macho, masculine appeal to it. The S60 sedan however, is sweet, sexy, safe and startling – all at the same time. If the XC60 is a go-anywhere-but-still-look-hot Lara Croft, the S60 is Wonderwoman. And all this even before you have settled into the orthopedically designed driver’s seat. I have a good feeling about this.

Solid start:
The S60, now in its second reincarnation, was conceived when Volvo was still owned by Ford, and before the company was handed over to its Chinese owners Geely much more recently. This was still a time when the Swedish carmaker that has had ‘safe’ as its USP over the decades was trying to reinvent itself, go more upmarket and stylish to eat into the entry-level luxury sedan market, dominated by the Germans. As a carmaker Volvo has had its fundamentals right over all these years – in fact the world record for the highest mileage in a car is held by a 1966 Volvo P1800, which has run 45 lakh kilometers, and is still running. The S60 however was a part of the company’s plans to revitalize the image, and did manage to break away from its earlier, boxy design philosophy. But when the current version was shown off at the Geneva Motor Show last year, the world stood up and took notice. Read letched.

And why would it not. The latest S60 was penned by Brit designer Steve Mattin, who was the chief of Volvo design until recently, and had been making a career in designing cars since he was 15. What has come off the boards though is a car that easily has the most presence in its segment. Our pet grouse with European entry-level sedans has been that they often end up having fairly unremarkable design, while yet demanding high price tags, mostly for the badges. Not the S60 though, which appeals to conventional car design proportions and aesthetics, yet offering generous dollops of modernity and fresh ideas when it comes to the exteriors.




Exteriors:
To start with, it has the aura of a four-door coupe which makes for an instantly appealing stance, only enhanced by the smart use of lines along the sides to impart a lithe, muscular aura to the package. The large Volvo badge that runs across the grille makes for a confident and proud statement of the company, but the real skill of the design team behind the S60 lies in making the whole fascia gel, with the swoopy headlamps and a friendly, smiling grille. The coupe-like rounded off roof meets the strong waistline, the flared-out rear fenders and the chunky rear bumper connection in a smart tail, with a rising swoop at the boot for enough silhouette entertainment to last a few years.

Parts bin:
Under its skin, the S60 comes with impressive credentials. What is called the Volvo Y20 platform is actually Ford’s versatile and proven EUCD, which carries cars ranging from big brother S80, the Ford Mondeo, even the Land Rover Freelander 2. While the platform has been around for a while, the new S60 has sufficiently tightened up bits that shine once the car is put through its paces. Just for academic interest though, the car features a redesigned chassis that is 47 percent stiffer than its predecessor, tauter springs and bushes in the suspension, and a quickened up steering. Now to pop the hood.




Volvo India has played it smart when it comes to engines options for us, which happen to be the most powerful petrol and diesel units in the S60 range respectively. We got our hands on the T6 variant, which is powered by a hopping mad inline-6, turbocharged petrol engine which puts out 305PS of power and 440Nm of torque, the pushing power figure especially impressive given that this is a 3-litre petrol mill. Mated with a super-quick-slick 6-speed automatic transmission and put down on the road through a Haldex all-wheel drive system, the big push is not spewed out – it flows out more like a ribbon of thrust.

SLIDESHOW: Kunal's handiwork!

 



Interiors:
As you step inside and shut the solid door, you are greeted by fairly clean, almost antiseptic interiors. The choice of plastics and materials is top-notch, and the feeling of plushness is clear and no-nonsense. The seats themselves are some of the most comfortable in automobiles, and the fact that a fair amount of research has been put in their design is obvious. There isn’t too much excitement on the dashboard, but somehow the view from the driver’s seat is not boring at all. Blame it on the heads-up display that keeps lighting the windscreen up if traffic inches too close, or the blind spot information system that shows up as a small but conspicuous blinking light on the A-pillar, there is always something to keep the driver aware. Apart from the numerous gizmos and gadgets that are now almost standard fitments in all Volvos, the S60 boasts of an advanced pedestrian recognition system, using bits borrowed from military-tech, no less! This state of the art safety feature is a boon for city drivers, and remains active under 40 kmph. A number of cameras allow the car to ‘see’ an obstacle in its path, and should the driver not react, the car will automatically bring the vehicle to a halt before hitting the obstacle. It’s not the smoothest braking, but it does get the job done and should also wake the driver up!




The drive:
The S60 in its T6 garb has an uncanny ability to transform from a comfortable family sedan to a roaring driver’s machine, blessed with grip from all four driving and dripping with feedback, in the time it takes to push the pedal to its deepest recess. While doing all this though, the car never lets go of its basic genetics – those of a strong, solid sedan, which is not a mean feat to achieve, and goes far in distinguishing this baby from its direct rivals, which characteristically excel, but fixate on one particular quality for their users.

0-100 km/h comes up in a blazing fast 7.1 seconds and car accelerates from 40 to 120 km/h in kickdown in a scant 8.5 seconds, aided massively by the slick gear shifts from the gearbox.  Just the quality of this box is in the league of the twin-clutch contraptions that we have been seeing in the Volkswagens and Skodas, and its ability to judge the right gear for the condition is impressive. That being said, the S60 is not all about acceleration and is happy to hum along at a tonful of speed with precious little noise seeping into the cabin.




And while you are in the middle of finding out how strong the acceleration is, or how refined the cruising, you may just miss out on how good the suspension really is. Our test car was equipped with the FOUR-C suspension – Volvo’s pet name for the active, adaptive suspension, which has dampers that recalibrate themselves on the fly using information from sensors all over. The sensors calculate body roll, yaw, the road surface and the driver’s mood through the steering wheel and throttle position to provide an almost seamless transition between mild and wild, seldom losing sight of the car’s family-sedan purpose. This matter stays consistent through the three suspension settings – Normal, Sport and Advanced, which plays a major role in giving the car its versatile mannerisms.




Final words:
So, a good-looking car that drives really well, remains composed and comfortable no matter what you throw at it, and presents an alternative image of its owner – so what’s the catch? It is no secret that Volvo does not demand the sort of brand equity that the German trio of Audi, BMW and Mercedes-Benz do. That being said, the new S60 does almost everything just right, which is all that a segment challenger can do.

But what sets the Swedish effort apart is the perfect sense it makes for its intended customers here in India. The entry-level luxury segment has seen a massive rise over the last few years, resulting in an overcrowding of C-Classes and 3 Series, especially in the metros. Now for a space where buyers like to distinguish themselves from the crowd, landing up in another crowd doesn’t quite make sense. The S60 offers exactly this option, with greater comfort, performance and panache. And that is as compelling an argument as any in favour of a car that prepares to make its mark.





Specifications and test data:

Engine: 3.0 Litre, Turocharged Inline-6 cylinder
Power: 304PS @ 5,600rpm
Torque: 440Nm @ 2,100 - 4,200rpm
Transmission: 6-speed Automatic, AWD

Wheelbase: 2,776mm
Length: 4,628mm
Width: 2,097mm
Height: 1,484mm




0-60 km/h: 3.76 sec
0-100 km/h: 7.19 sec
Overtaking acceleration in kickdown (40-120 km/h): 8.55 sec
Braking 80-0 km/h: 2.31sec, 26.67 metres
Braking 100-0 km/h: 2.99sec, 41.40 metres
Fuel efficiency (overall): 9 kmpl
Price: T6 Summum variant: Rs 34 lakh, ex-showroom Delhi
                             







BMW 650i : Road Test

by Muntaser Mirkar Photography : Kunal Khadse Posted on 08 Jul 2009836 Views0 Comments
40 degrees temperatures, possibly one of the toughest summers in the country that I've seen in my short existence. Scorching heat, rising humidity and mirages aplenty on every horizon are a sure shot indication of a persistent summer season that looks like it will stick on forever and get even worse. Summer - perfect weather to get the top down on that convertible you just bought and enjoy pure, natural environmental bliss, right? If you're in Europe that would've been just perfect, but not exactly true for India now, is it? So then, what do you do with a Rs 1.25 crore piece of Germany's best machinery that allows you to put the top down and drive around in style? Well, you close the hood and switch on the air conditioning of course!


Get alerts on new cars reviewed by ZigWheels



And that's just what we ended up doing almost the whole time that we drove around in the magnificent BMW 650i convertible. So while topless motoring might not be the call of the hour in sizzling India at the moment, could the 650i show any bouts of practicality at all in our country, especially at that price? It's a valid question, and that's what we're going to find out.


Sleek silhouetted sharp machine

As with all things penned by BMW from the Chris Bangle era, the 650i induced mixed reactions from everyone in the office. We had obviously seen the car in pictures before, but watching that low slung, sleek silhouette crouched in position ready for attack is just a completely different experience altogether. At first, the stance of the car apart, individual design elements seem out of place, the headlights look like the car's squinting, the long bonnet looks out of proportion and the integrated spoiler on the boot lid sticks out like a sore thumb. But it's when you take a couple of steps back and soak in the entirety of the 650i that you begin to fall in love with Bangle's genius. All of a sudden all those irritating individual bits fall right into place with each other to create perfect harmony all the way from the kidney grille in the front to the swooping tail lights at the back. And all of that is before you put that top up.







Keep the small button on the central console pressed and the 650i will get its soft top up in just over 20 second, provided you're travelling at 30km/h or less. The way the top is designed is simply outstanding. Instead of looking like an afterthought (like in many other convertibles) the 650i's unit gels perfectly well with not only the A pillar, but also with the short boot at the back. Considering that most 650i's will be driving around town with the top up rather than down in our weather, the seamless integrity of the roof with the rest of the car is an unmistakable boon to the car's visual appeal.

Jump in and brace yourself!

Once you've sunk into the low seats of the 650i it is typical German fare as far the interiors go. There is no mistaking this car for any other German marque either, you get in and you instantly know this is a BMW and it can be nothing else. Peering through from behind the three spoke steering wheel is the typical BMW instrument console layout. The car also gets the iDrive system, but not the latest generation one found on the 7-series.




Probably the biggest departure for the 650i from other siblings from the BMW stables is on the co-driver side with a bottle holder sticking out from the centre console. Seats are extremely comfortable and offer great support to both driver and co-driver. The 650i is a long car and owing to its wheelbase, it also gets a second row of seats. Two average height adults can fit in the rear bench if it's going to be just a short drive, unless they want to freeze with their legs bent in for the rest of their lives. There's ample space for kids though.


V8 rumble,  hair raising!




BMWs may be known for their inline 6 engines but under the huge expanse of the 650i's bonnet is a massive 4799cc V8 which combines Double vanos and Valvetronic technology to deliver an unforgettable driving experience. All those technical terms translate into no less than 367PS of power and 490 Nm of torque! Thumb that start/stop button and the V8 rumbles into life with a slight burble before settling down into a smooth hum. With all those horses available at a dab of the throttle there's no doubt about the fact that the 650i is going to be one quick car, but what really excites is the flexibility of the motor. The 4.8 litre V8 powerplant is extremely driveable and even if max power kicks in at a high 6300rpm, it never feels like it's gasping for air.






That monster V8 is coupled to a six-speed sport automatic transmission which facilitates some super-quick gear shifts to harness the full potential of the V8. The auto 'box also allows the driver to switch to manual mode and shift gears using the gear selector lever itself, or by using the innovative pedals on the steering wheel. Unlike in most cars that employ paddle shifts (right to upshift, left to downshift), the 650i's paddle shift shifts up a gear when pulled and downshifts when pushed no matter whether you?re using the left or right paddle. This quite clearly eliminates any kind of confusion in up and downshifting especially when you're in the middle of making a turn - a neat touch indeed. Flick on the sport mode with the tiny button behind the gear selector lever and the 650i will perform even quicker shifts through the 'box.

Pedal to the metal





If you've had any doubts about the 650i being a good performer, one look at the car's technical specifications should be enough to set that record straight. The BMW 650i convertible will accelerate from 0-100km/h in just over 7.6 seconds. No matter where you are in the rev range, the car just keeps pulling clean and strong. The car's top speed test saw us return with mile-wide smiles plastered all across our faces - 255.65km/h on our instrumented test machinery with the speedometer needle way past the marked 250km/h indication. Braking was spot on too - the large discs all round hauling the 650i to a stop from 100km/h in just 3.1 seconds and 42.5 metres.






All of the above may not be surprising at all - and quite frankly it was expected. What really made us such big fans of the 650i was the car's impeccable handling - after all it's a BMW! And what took the cake in the end was the way the 650i handled broken tarmac on Pune's roads. You see, the 6 uses 245/45 R19 tyres up front and 275/35 R19 tyres at the back - both pairs being Runflats. Now, that amounts to some really low profile tyres all round which should theoretically translate into a rather rough ride. But what the 650i lacks in tyre profile, it makes up with sheer size - the massive 19-inch tyre diameter coupled with the well-tuned suspension setup soaking out bumps and grinds with ease. The car is still pretty low mind you, so driving over some of our 'neatly crafted' mountainous speed breakers may lead to bit of heartburn.

Got Rs 1.25 crore to spare?






The 650i isn't the car for every garage - even if you have the required amount of money to spare. Even with that rear bench it is still a two-seater for all practical purposes. Our wonderful climate (especially in summers), makes it almost foolish to drive with the top down unless you have an affinity for a severe tan, lungs full of carbon monoxide and nostrils clogged with dust. After having read the above statement, if you still have even a small liking for the 650i, this car belongs to you. After all, for someone with that kind of money there are hardly any better options as far as head turners go. And then you always have the option of driving with the top down after sundown. Fuel efficiency isn't worse than other comparable cars either. So all things considered, the BMW 650i still makes for a rather interesting addition to that already multi-crore garage.




                                      TOYOTA YARIS 2012 ROAD TEST
TOYOTA YARIS 2012

Pros

Pleasant handling; impressive safety features; assertive sheet metal.

Cons

Navigation system isn't available; less cargo capacity than some rivals.

Six as Great as Eight

By Warren Clarke, Automotive Content Editor
Toyota executives introduce the 2012 Toyota Yaris at a trendy Culver City eatery overrun with cartoonlike sculptures and angst-ridden paintings; it's the kind of place that calls itself a "café/shop/art space." The youthful vibe of the location is no accident, what with Toyota hoping to snare a younger buyer (via an all-digital campaign, naturally) with this new, second-generation Yaris.
Of course, you need more than just targeted marketing to make this happen. Though last year's modest 106-horsepower 1.5-liter engine remains, more emphasis has been placed on making the Yaris fun to drive, and our test car is part of an all-new SE trim that features sharper steering and a sport-tuned suspension. Every Yaris gets assertive new sheet metal and spruced-up cabins — no more awkward, center-mounted gauges. And the previous generation's pitiful cargo capacity sees some improvement, with the current model offering up to 68 percent more room for your luggage.
Toyota also hopes to set the Yaris apart on the strength of its safety features, and the car is equipped with nine standard airbags and front seats designed to mitigate whiplash injury.
Overall, it's not a bad package, but it's not enough to make us forget the well-rounded Ford Fiesta, the versatile Honda Fit or the refined Hyundai Accent. Still, this new 2012 Toyota Yaris is undeniably good-looking and pleasant to drive. Factor in its impressive safety amenities along with Toyota's record for reliability and it's easy to see the car striking the right balance for certain buyers.

Performance

The 2012 Toyota Yaris is powered by a 1.5-liter inline-4 good for 106 hp and 103 pound-feet of torque. It's the same engine seen in the outgoing model, but this time around it has less weight to move, since the current Yaris is lighter by about 40 pounds or so. In our test car, the engine is teamed with a new four-speed automatic transmission (a six-speed manual is also available). A four-speed automatic may seem low-tech given that there are many six-speed automatics in this segment, but the setup deserves credit for going about its business without the excessive, fuel-conscious downshifting seen in transmissions offered by larger compact sedans like the Chevrolet Cruze.
While the Yaris certainly isn't one of the quicker choices in this segment, there's enough pep on hand to allow you to navigate both city and freeway traffic with no panicked moments. And what our SE test car lacks in speed, it makes up for by way of its affable handling; it feels light and spry on the road, and maintains its composure in corners.
Our test car's driving dynamics represent an improvement over those of the previous Yaris, and that's exactly as Toyota planned it; the SE features a sport-tuned suspension designed to make the daily commute more enjoyable. Steering is quicker as well, and the chassis has been engineered for a tauter, more together feel even as a wheelbase that's 2 inches longer makes the ride more stable and comfortable.
With the automatic transmission, the Yaris gets EPA-rated mileage of 30 city/35 highway mpg and 32 mpg combined. These figures are quite respectable — the base model Honda Fit gets 28/35/31 and the Nissan Versa gets 24/32/27. Still, buyers who want an even more frugal choice will want to take a look at the Hyundai Accent (30/40/33) and Ford Fiesta with the SFE option (29/40/33).

Comfort

One consequence of the SE's keener suspension is ride quality that falls on the stiffer side of the spectrum, but there's still enough comfort in the mix to keep the car well-behaved on the road. Most surface unpleasantness is capably neutralized.
The front seats are perched high to present commanding views of the road ahead. The SE model features sport seats, but they're flatter and less aggressively bolstered than most others we've encountered, which makes them suitable even for wider drivers. The chairs are well-padded and supportive, and serve as an agreeable roost throughout the three or so hours we spend piloting the Yaris through Los Angeles and Santa Monica on our test loop.
There's some road and tire noise to be heard as the 2012 Toyota Yaris navigates surface streets, and when we hit the highway, wind noise also makes an appearance. None of it is excessive, but if you're a stickler for cabin serenity, keep in mind that the Accent offers a quieter time behind the wheel.

Function

As is the case with most economy cars, the Yaris boasts a control layout that's blessedly intuitive; heat and air-conditioning are governed by a familiar three-knob setup. Audio controls are managed via a handful of logically placed buttons and knobs; four buttons to the left of the center stack allow you to select a band, and they're joined by a large volume control knob, and buttons to the bottom right that allow you to assign or select your favorite stations. The display screen is on the small side, but there's enough real estate to present information in an easily legible way.
Once upon a time, you didn't expect much by way of tech from cars in the Yaris' humble price range, but those days are well behind us. Our SE features Bluetooth with phonebook access, music streaming via Bluetooth wireless technology and an iPod interface. There's also a USB port, though we wish it had been placed in a less awkward location; it's found deep in the roof of the glovebox.
One tech feature you won't find in the 2012 Toyota Yaris is a factory-installed navigation system. However, we suspect that this is less of an issue these days than it was in times past, since there are currently tons of portable and handheld navigation units on the market that do the job for thousands less than the costly factory-installed systems you get with a new car.
There's not much by way of in-cabin storage. There's no center console bin and the door bins are small, though they are equipped to fit taller water bottles.
On the plus side, though, the Yaris' backseat is surprisingly spacious, with lots of legroom. Additionally, since the front seats are mounted high off the ground, they offer ample space underneath where those seated in the second row can plant their toes and feet if they need to.
At 15.6 cubic feet, cargo capacity in our SE represents a big improvement over that of the previous Yaris. Still, it trails that of many others in this segment; you'll get more utility with the Fit (20.6 cubic feet), Accent (21.2 cubic feet) and Versa (17.8 cubic feet).
Visibility is decent from most angles, thanks to the car's generous greenhouse.

Design/Fit and Finish

With its heroic square jaw and lower stance (0.6 inch shorter than its predecessor), the 2012 Toyota Yaris speaks a design language that's more forceful than that of the previous generation. The cabin design is simple yet attractive; the center stack, especially, is intuitively laid out, while at the same time reflecting modern flair.
Materials quality is good for this segment, though not especially ambitious. Buttons feel stable and secure, and knobs turn with precise, well-damped movement.

Who should consider this vehicle

Though the 2012 Toyota Yaris is marketed toward younger drivers, the car is a decent fit for drivers of all ages who want a small, inexpensive car with amenable driving dynamics and good-looking sheet metal. It trails cars like the Accent and Fiesta in highway mileage; still, its respectable city and combined mileage figures make it a solid pick for fuel-conscious drivers who spend lots of time on surface streets.

Monday, October 17, 2011

COMPARISONS

          

New Audi A6 vs BMW 5 Series vs Mercedes E-Class : Comparison

 

 Indisputably the most dominant forces in the executive luxury sedan segment, the three german kings, the BMW 5 Series, the Audi A6 and the Mercedes-benz E-Class fight it out for supremacy in the six-cylinder petrol arena



Get alerts on new cars reviewed by ZigWheels


Mirror, mirror on the wall, which is the best executive luxury sedan of them all? It’s the one question that just begs to be answered, doesn’t it? Even though many of us will never have the means to buy one of these Teutonic treats, these three, the Mercedes-Benz E-Class, the BMW 5 Series and the Audi A6 that is, represent the quintessential automotive aspirations for most of us – out of reach, yet bearing a hint of attainability. And while these three cars might don different badges and sport different lines, they symbolize pretty much the same auto-ethos – luxury, practicality (in context of course) and a great driving experience. The launch of a new replacement model in this lot, then deserves the other two to be dragged out of bed in the wee hours of the morning and thrown into ring for a right old fight. And if we’re going to have a tussle on our hands, we might as well get the most fun engines, the V6 petrol motors that is, which are on offer.

The car that has prompted all this is the new A6 from Audi. After the highly capable, but rather staid looking previous generation of the car, this follow up is all set to correct the shortcomings of its predecessor. But the competition isn’t exactly long in the tooth either. The latest E-Class is barely a couple of years old while the 5 Series only just arrived last year. And while all three might have similar capabilities, each has its own unique appeal. So if you’re the sort of person who is in the market for a luxury sedan and has about 50-odd lakh rupees to spare or if you, like most of us, are a keen auto enthusiast who just wants to know which one of these stands above the rest, the answer isn’t so cut-and-dry. Nevertheless, the following point-by-point comparison should lift the veil on this mystery once and for all, or at least until the next iteration of one of these comes along and ups the game a notch.

Beauty spot
Beauty, as they say, is in the eye of the beholder. And that brings us to a dilemma because there is absolutely nothing wrong with the way any one of these cars looks. The current generation of the E-Class, the W212, stands head and shoulders over the last couple of generations of the car. Gone are the strange oval headlights, replaced by what almost look like gigantic diamonds set in the front fascia. The overall lines have been sharpened up a bit too, ditching the gentle, and rather ungainly, curves for edges which not only carry the shape of what is now accepted to be a modern E-Class saloon, but bring back memories of the E124 from the mid-80s – the best looking E-Class of all time in our opinion.

In terms of its looks, the current 5 Series on the other hand has been taken a notch down, if you ask us. With designer Chris Bangle’s design language notably absent, the 5 has lost a bit of its edge. Gone are those curvaceous headlights and that famous “Bangle-butt”. But all of this isn’t necessarily a bad thing. While the earlier 5 was a “love-it-or-hate-it” affair, this one is much more palatable and far classier. The move to more traditional design cues seems to have rather helped this car’s case, and it pretty much stands on equal footing in comparison to its traditional rival, the E-Class. However, in our opinion, this Bimmer scores just a smidgen more than the Merc, thanks to its slightly sleeker proportions.






The new A6 on the other hand is a whole other story. Had this story been done a couple of months back, when we still had the earlier A6, the Merc and the BMW would have utterly trounced it in terms of looks. The problem with the A6, and most of Audi’s sedans, was that it looked like just ‘a car’ – any generic car. But this new car has really upped the ante by a large margin. Sharper, more muscular lines, a new front air-dam, all-LED head lights and even a redesigned rear end with an integrated spoiler lip make the new A6 really stand apart in this company. And one doesn’t have to say too much about it either – just the sight of this car standing amidst its competition should be enough for anyone to see which car has the upper hand. And if we need to spell that out for you, it’s the A6.


Pedal to the metal
Granted that these executive luxury sedans are mostly going to be enjoyed from the comfort of the rear seats, but since we’ve got our mitts on the most exciting engines that they offer, we might as well have a full-on performance comparo. The Mercedes-Benz E350, true to its name, sports a 3.5-litre V6 direct-injection petrol engine, which is the only naturally aspirated one of these three. So obviously, engine outputs are nothing to write home about – 272PS of power and 355Nm of torque. When trying to propel a car that has a kerb weight of 1732kg, the zero to 100km/h time is 7.49 seconds. But the E-Class isn’t really about neck snapping acceleration figures. With the 7-speed G-TRONIC automatic gearbox, the E simply wafts about, in a manner most becoming of a luxury saloon.






The 535i on the other hand comes equipped with the traditional BMW inline 6-cylinder engine featuring direct injection and a twin-scroll turbo charge to ensure that the 2,979cc petrol motor manages a power output of 306PS which is sent to the rear wheels through an 8-speed automatic gearbox. But the power delivery of the new 5 has been significantly smoothened compared to its predecessor. So even though it might have E-Class beating performance, it feels like BMW is trying to make its own E-Class. And this means that even though the car is highly capable, it goes a long way in offending BMW purists.

The Audi A6’s 3-litre V6 direct injection petrol motor uses another form of forced induction to bump up its output – supercharging – and manages to make 300PS of power. Now while that is less than the BMW 535i, Audi’s brings a 7-speed twin-clutch gearbox and Quattro permanent four-wheel drive to the fight. So off the line, the A6 is much quicker, making the dash to 100km/h from naught in just 6.46 seconds. And it’s not just the quarter-mile where the Audi trumps the rest. The same gearbox and 4WD system give the A6 unparalleled grip when the going gets twisty and that coupled with the brilliant dynamic steering system inspire great confidence when chucking the car around corners.






The inside story
Practically speaking, very few folks are ever going to care if one of these is 0.1 seconds quicker to 100 than the other. The larger part of the appeal of these cars is how they make you feel, and a big chunk of that comes from the view from behind the wheel, or maybe from the back seat. In this department though, it is the BMW that tends to suffer a bit. Mind you, there’s nothing wrong with the interiors of the 5 Series. But then again, there’s not so much to write home about either. The Spartan appointments might work for the performance enthusiast, but don’t do much for anyone looking for a real premium feel from their luxury sedan.

The Audi A6 manages to much better in this department. The cabin is absolutely filled to the brim with toys and the lovely walnut brown, black and wood finish interiors are such a welcome change from the standard luxury beige. But the inherent problem with the A6’s interiors, even though they’re extremely fresh and modern is that they already feels like they’ve been done to death. After having been inside the new A8 and the A7, you’ll be hard pressed to tell what they’ve changed in the A6 – it’s that similar.

So as strange as it might seem, we think that the Mercedes-Benz E-Class has the best interiors of this lot. They don’t really feel sporty or modern, but if you ask us, they don’t need to. A luxury car should have luxuriously appointed interiors and the E-Class manages this really well. The choice of colours, materials and textures is extremely tasteful and while it might not have the ‘space-ship’ feel of the Audi, it feels elegant in a way neither of the two others can manage. And if you peel away all the old-school veneer, you’ll see that the E-Class does in fact have almost all the goodies that the other two have.




Verdict: The new kid takes the crown
In this segment of executive luxury cars, it is somewhat difficult to narrow down to one car and say this is the better one of the lot, this is the one you must buy. Here, most of the buying decisions happen based on brand loyalty or badge value. So you’ll rarely see a Mercedes-Benz buyer considering walking into a BMW or Audi showroom. But when we’ve got such a podium ceremony lined up, a winner we must choose.

Let’s start with the Mercedes-Benz E-Class then. This latest generation is a solid car and manages the luxury bit better than the other two. Where it loses out in performance and good looks, it makes up for in sheer opulence. Driving the Merc was definitely the most luxurious experience of this lot and it’s something that will appeal to a lot of folks. And let’s not forget the power of the 3-pointed star badge on the nose – that itself is worth its weight in gold for many.





The BMW 5-series on the other hand is a slightly confusing proposition. Sure, it’s better in most ways than the Merc, but if you’ve tasted the previous generation 5, one can’t help feel a slight disappointment about the direction in which BMW has decided to go with this new car. But it’s a great package overall – brilliant performance, handsome looks and then there’s that wonderful straight-six motor which just stands apart from the standard V6 formula.

But the runaway winner of this comparison has to be the new A6. Of course, it has its share of flaws, most important of which is the fact it doesn’t do too much, especially on the insides, to distinguish itself from the other Audi sedans of this generation. But then again, it is the quickest one of this lot, has the best handling, the most modern interiors and is utterly gorgeous to look at from the outside.




What Audi has done very cleverly with this new A6 is not try and change the formula for what makes its sedans so delectable. That perfect harmony of handling and ride quality, confidence inspiring grip of the four-wheel drive system and clever, yet very useful gadgetry is all maintained. What’s been given the boot is the rather staid looks which had come to be associated with the previous model as well as that ridiculous automatic gearbox which totally ruined the experience of the exhilarating supercharged direct-injection 6-cylinder petrol motor. So in a nutshell, if it’s an executive luxury sedan you want, then you really can’t go wrong with any of these. But if it’s a complete automotive experience you crave, then the choice doesn’t get clearer than the new Audi A6.




 

Toyota Corolla Altis vs Skoda Laura vs Chevrolet Cruze : Comparison

by Rahul Basu Posted on 10 Jun 201123529 Views6 Comments
Both the Laura and the Cruze have had the market pretty much for themselves till the arrival of the Toyota Corolla Altis Diesel. We look at how these three premium diesel powered sedans fare against one another

Get alerts on new cars reviewed by ZigWheels

At first glance, all three cars looks quite good, and nothing really sets one apart from the other, expect maybe the Chevrolet Cruze that definitely comes across as the most well-chiseled of the lot. While, the new Corolla’s lines and styling is to a great extend inspired by the larger Camry model, the car does come across as bold and attractive in its own right. The Laura on the other hand is just as sophisticated to look at as you would expect with most Skoda models. But in the overall looks department, the Cruze certainly takes a leap forward owing to its muscular, chiseled, attitude oozing styling.


On the inside, all three cars are quite comfortable, as you would expect in sedans competing at this level. But where the spaciousness is concerned, the Cruze certainly takes a beating, as compared to the Laura and more importantly the Altis, which is roomiest of the lot.


Lifting the hood, we see a different power game arising among the three contenders. First up is the 2.0-litre DOHC mill of the Skoda Laura that is capable of pumping out 140 PS @ 4000 rpm and a tyre balding 320 Nm of torque. Next up is the Japanese contenders D-4D series engines, which though the smallest of the lot is also one of the most technologically advanced. It produces 88.4 PS @ 3800 rpm and 205 Nm of rotational force @ 2800 rpm, which the engine makes in a very linear and absolutely flat torque curve. But the real match winner is the 2.0 litre VCDi unit in the Cruze which boosts output to 150 PS @ 4000 rpm and a very impressive 327 Nm of torque.





Getting to the numbers, the 100 km/h sprint in the Cruze is covered in just 11.6 seconds and keeping the throttle buried sees the speedo needle go north of 200 km/h with ease.  In the Laura, the 100 km/h comes up in a quicker 11.44 seconds with a top speed close to 200 km/h. Outright performance can be termed just about adequate on the Altis with the 100 km/h mark coming up in 14.55 seconds. In terms of top speed, the Altis runs out of breath at a shade over 170 km/h.


Where fuel efficiency is concerned, the Cruze returned an overall figure of 12.41 kmpl, while the Laura managed 11 kmpl in the city and 14 kmpl on the highways. The mileage champion in the group however is the Corolla Altis. Managing 14.2 kmpl around town, and an unbelievable 24.3 kmpl on the highway.

SLIDESHOW:


With prices starting at Rs. 10,95,000 and going upto Rs. 13,75,000 for the top end variant, the Altis is one to pick blindly if space and fuel economy are big considerations. The Cruze retailing between Rs. 11,52,254 and Rs. 13,95,982, however does offers a better ride quality, explosive performance and great looks. Asking for a lakh more than the Cruze and the Corolla, the Laura is by far the ‘priciest’ of the lot, selling for anything between Rs. 14,89,376 - Rs. 18,01,407. So if money is no object the Laura makes for a pretty satisfying buy as it has the best build quality of the lot and is also the classier car by far.




Verdict:
Either ways you can't go wrong with any of the cars mentioned above. It's just a matter of establishing one's priority which makes the decision even simpler.